Drexel Gibson and the Berlitz School

“One such American prisoner is Drexel Gibson, an American businessman who was arrested in Cuba on April 19, and since that time has been imprisoned….The latest information I have received is that the Swiss Embassy in Havana, through which discussions with the Cuban Government are taking place, reports that Mr. Gibson is being investigated for “activities against the state.””

HON. PRESCOTT BUSH
OF CONNECTICUT
IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES
Monday, June 26,1961 (1)

Who was Drexel Gibson?

Drexel Gibson
‘What a nightmare!’ Says American in Cuban Jail (3)
Drexel Gibson was the owner of the Berlitz School of Languages in Havana, Cuba.  He had been operating the school for a little over two years.  His wife and son resided with him in Cuba until July of 1960, at which time his wife and son returned to the United States because of an existing medical condition in his son, that required multiple surgeries. (2)  He had returned to Havana to get his affairs in order as he intended to move back to the United States.  All of this changed on April 17, 1961 when the failed Bay of Pigs invasion took place.

 

The Imprisonment of Drexel Gibson

On April 19, 1963 Drexel Gibson arrived to find Cuban G-2 Agents, tearing apart his office.  He was promptly arrested and detained by the government. Many Americans were arrested as a result of the failed invasion. (4) Gibson was subjected to intense interrogation, as he was accused by the Castro government of working as an intelligence agent on behalf of the FBI, not the CIA.  His interrogations lasted for more than one month as they attempted to break him.  They wanted him to identify his “network” of spies and his methods for communicating with the FBI. (5) Gibson explained that he was subjected to psychological torture.  He was not fed, slept on a floor, and over his six interrogation sessions subjected to over one hundred hours of interrogation.  While there he suffered a broken finger that was not treated, resulting in his finger being permanently paralyzed. (6)

Was Drexel Gibson working for the FBI?

Gibson claimed that the entire focus of his interrogation was around the FBI.  After his month of interrogation he was moved to a prison.  There he was interrogated as well.  He was offered deals to cooperate, for example, medicine that he needed to treat an ulcer.  He did not confess.  Gibson had a theory about why the Cuban’s thought he was working for the FBI.

When Gibson returned home to be with his son in March of 1961 during his surgery, Gibson went to meet with the president of the Berlitz schools.  It was in this meeting that Gibson explained that there were some strange goings on at his school.  He was concerned with the growing number of employees that were Castro sympathizers.  It was on his advice that Gibson contacted the FBI and provided them with information on his employees. (7) Gibson believed that somehow, because of this meeting with the FBI, G-2 found out about it, and this was why they were interrogating him.

Cuban Intelligence interest in the Berlitz School Employees

arcazweb
Berlitz School of Languages (9)
Gibson reported to the FBI that there were a growing number of Castro sympathizers associated with his school. Not only did the FBI have an interest, but when he was interrogated by the Cuban Government during his incarceration, they too questioned him extensively about his employees.  (8) Gibson reported on the following employees and their associates to the FBI, Harold Spencer, Martha McCurdy, Iilah Warner, Claudia Beck, Angela Motsis, Rosanna Carfagno, and Christine Olson de Urriutia.  Some of these individuals had ties to the Fair Play for Cuba Committee.  Others had ties to Cuban intelligence, or worked for the Castro government. One had a relationship with Fidel Castro himself.  The Berlitz School was quite an interesting place, and Gibson had reason to be concerned.

Harold Spencer – Fair Play for Cuba

The_Times_Sun__Jul_21__1963_
The Times (Hammond, Indiana) July 21, 1963  (10)
In the CIA files on the Fair Play for Cuba Committee is potential verification that Gibson did report his concerns. One American that Gibson reported on was attorney Harold Spencer, who was from Chicago.  Spencer’s American wife was also employed by the Cuban government in the Ministry of Arts.  He was a leader of the Fair Play for Cuba Committee in Havana, an organization that had some of the Berlitz school employees. (11)

Spencer was described by one American newspaper as the

NARA Record Number: 1993.08.03.17:13:42:400063 INDEX CARDS
INDEX CARDS for CIA file  100-300-011 (13)
leader of over 150 American supporters of Castro in Cuba.  He hosted an English speaking radio show and was described as having a “squeaky” voice.  In the CIA files is file number 100-300-011 which was a file called the Fair Play for Cuba Committee (FPCC).  It consisted of 987 documents. The bulk of the documents were generated from the FBI and other agencies.  Inside of this file is information about Harold Spencer.  The information about Harold Spencer was placed into the CIA file after the interview with Gibson. This file also contained an FBI report about Lee Harvey Oswald being arrested in New Orleans for his activities involving the FPCC.   (12)

Ilah Werner and Berlitz School employee Martha McCurdy along with Harold Spencer celebrate July 4th in Havana while Drexel Gibson was imprisoned.
Ilah Werner and Berlitz School employee Martha McCurdy along with Harold Spencer celebrate July 4th in Havana while Drexel Gibson was imprisoned. (16)

Martha McCurdy and Illah Warner

The report of the interview with Gibson contained information about multiple Americans and Cubans employed by the Berlitz School.  Gibson reported that Martha McCurdy, one of his teachers since 1958, was a member of the Fair Play for Cuba Committee. She was still in Cuba and lived with another American, Illah Warner, also a member of the committee. (14) In a newspaper editorial about Americans who went to Cuba to support Castro, the two ladies were described as “veteran” Castro supporters who worked for the cause in Miami and fled to Cuba in 1959. (15)

 

 

Claudia Beck & Angela Motsis

Another American that Gibson had employed was Claudia Beck.   She was no longer employed by the school, but was currently employed in the Cuban Ministry of Education.   One of his teachers, Angela Motsis, was married to a “Greek who was deported from the US and who now works in the Cuban G-2 as a technician.” Again, it is curious to see that there was such a close tie to the Cuban intelligence world working for his business. (17)

Rosanna Carfagno

Another employee of interest was Rosanna Carfagno, who was from NY.  She was arrested  at the same time as Gibson, but according to Gibson, she was released because friends of Castro had intervened on her behalf.  She most certainly did have important friends, Fidel Castro being one of them.  He met her in 1959 during his “Meet the Press Interview” in April of 1959. They spent time touring New York together and then on her Christmas vacation she went to Cuba, spent time with Castro, and was seen holding hands with him.  (18) Eventually she would move to Cuba and be employed by Drexel Gibson at the Berlitz School.

Christine Olson de Urriutia

Gibson informed the FBI about Christine Olson de Urriutia, who was married to the former president of Cuba under Castro.  Gibson states she was one of the best teachers he ever had, did not think she was active in groups, but was probably for Castro.  One of her close friends was married to Lorna Pinero.  Her husband, Manuel Pinero, worked for the Ministry of the Interior and G-2. Another employee with ties to the Cuban intelligence agency.  (19) Another employee with multiple connections to Castro and the Cuban government.

Was Drexel Gibson allowing the Berlitz School to be used to train anti-Casto rebels?

The document that contains the CIA interview with Gibson would indicate that he was not working with the CIA.  There are only two documents in the archives related to the Berlitz School and Gibson.  One document is an interview conducted by the Domestic Contacts Division of the CIA.  It was conducted after multiple interviews Gibson gave to the press.

Imigration Paperwork
Passenger List, October 31, 1961 (21)
Gibson was released on September 5, 1961.  He arrived back in Miami from Cuba with help from the Swiss government on October 31, 1961, yet there was no interview of him for months.The CIA did not interview him until December 23, 1961.  (20)This lack of interest and the fact that Gibson had been talking to the press prior to any contact by the CIA with him would mean that he was not of interest to the CIA.

 

Records show researcher Gaeton Fonzi never saw the CIA Gibson document.

The only person from the HSCA to review this document was Leslie Wizelman of the HSCA.   She saw the document as part of the review of the CIA files on John Martino. (22) At the time of her review of the document, the only part not redacted was one paragraph. The document had been redacted in 1962 to remove 3rd party information.  (23)

This redaction from 1962, is further proof that the CIA was not interested in the Berlitz School.  They were interested in the prisoner

Drexel Gibson Redacted
Gibson Redacted File viewed by HSCA (24)
with whom Drexel Gibson had been imprisoned with, John Martino. The rest was considered third party information.  According to this report, Gibson was not questioned at all about any sensitive materials, documents, or information that could have been found at the Berlitz School.  If there were training in the use of explosives conducted here, where was the evidence?  If the G-2 had searched his property fully and found something surely Gibson would have been executed as other Americans trying to overthrow Castro had been.

 

Ms. Wizelman would not have seen the information in 1978 about the Berlitz School based on the redactions.  According to the record sheet, this document was never seen by famed researcher Gaeton Fonzi, who was investigating leads in connection to the Berlitz School. The full document was released in 1993.  Gaeton Fonzi never wrote about Drexel Gibson in his book, The Last Investigation.  Nor was Gibson ever questioned by the HSCA in their investigation of the assassination of President Kennedy.

Additionally, the June Cobb file reviewed by HSCA staffer Edwin Lopez, contained information about Castro’s girlfriend and Berlitz Employee, Rosanna Carfagno.  There was nothing in the file that would indicate that Carfagno went on to work at the Berlitz School in Cuba.  If Lopez had made the connection, it would certainly been passed on to Gaeton Fonzi as he conducted his research into the alleged CIA connections with anti-Castro Cubans.

Unanswered Questions

One has to wonder if Gaeton Fonzi did know about Gibson, what information could have been gained in his quest for the truth?   What could have been learned if this lead had been followed? The questions that I am left with are more than when I started and it frustrates me as a researcher.  The answers that I am seeking are not here and they may have passed us by as Drexel Gibson passed away in 1998. (25)   The questions that remain in my mind continue to challenge me.

Would the CIA have used the Berlitz School to train anti-Castro revolutionaries  if there were so many people working there who were pro-Castro?

Why didn’t Cuban intelligence accuse Gibson of working for the CIA?  If they had evidence that Gibson was working for the US government, why was he allowed to leave Cuba, when so many other were not?  Does this alone mean that he was NOT working for the United States Government?

If the government were interested in Drexel Gibson and concerned about the implications of his arrest and imprisonment in relation to CIA covert operations, why did they wait over three months to interview him after his release from Cuban prison?  Is this not a sign that he and the school were not part of any operations against Castro?

Are any of the employees still alive?  Can they be tracked down to provide insight into the work that was happening at the Berlitz School?

When I have finished researching in the past, I have always felt a resolution in my work. In this case, I am feeling empty and unsatisfied.  I am upset, because I have seen the documents by the HSCA requesting information on this topic, and it is obvious to me, that this information never made it into the hands of the investigators charged by Congress to leave no stone unturned.

Matt “The Hitman” Scheufele

(1)  UNITED STATES OF AMERICA Congressional Record PROCEEDINGS AND DEBATES OF THE 87/A CONGRESS FIRST SESSION VOLUME 107—PART 9 JUNE 26, 1961, TO JULY 14, 1961 (PAGES 11167 TO 12620) UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE WASHINGTON, 1961)

(2) IBID

(3) ‘What a nightmare!’ Says American in Cuban Jail, The Pittsburgh Gazzette, November 26, 1961,  George Clifford

(4) IBID

(5)JOHN MARTINO: OS/SAG FILES PROVIDED TO THE HSCA, pg 9  NARA Record Number: 1993.07.21.09:15:26:960620

(6)  ‘What a nightmare!’ Says American in Cuban Jail, The Pittsburgh Gazzette, November 26, 1961,  George Clifford

(7) JOHN MARTINO: OS/SAG FILES PROVIDED TO THE HSCA, pg 9  NARA Record Number: 1993.07.21.09:15:26:960620

(8) JOHN MARTINO: OS/SAG FILES PROVIDED TO THE HSCA, pg 10  NARA Record Number: 1993.07.21.09:15:26:960620

(9) Berlitz School of Languages, Calle 23 No. 171, Vedado. (Today the Ministry of Sugar) http://www.bc.gob.cu/english/financial_institutions.asp

(10) The Times (Hammond, Indiana) July 21, 1963, Page 21

(11) JOHN MARTINO: OS/SAG FILES PROVIDED TO THE HSCA, pg 11  NARA Record Number: 1993.07.21.09:15:26:960620

(12) [RESTRICTED] (Deposition of Mrs. Ann Elizabeth Goldsborough Egerter)NARA Record Number: 180-10131-10333

(13) INDEX CARDS, NARA Record Number: 1993.08.03.17:13:42:400063

(14) JOHN MARTINO: OS/SAG FILES PROVIDED TO THE HSCA, pg 10  NARA Record Number: 1993.07.21.09:15:26:960620

(15) Americans Join Castro’s Ranks, Fulton Lewis Jr Lakeland Ledger – Dec 26, 1961, pg 4  

(16) “Americans in Cuba Celebrate July 4”, The Militant, July 10 and 17, 1961.

(17) JOHN MARTINO: OS/SAG FILES PROVIDED TO THE HSCA, pg 11  NARA Record Number: 1993.07.21.09:15:26:960620

(18) Reel 11, Folder B – CIA/DO/LA FILE ON VIOLA JUNE COBB AS REVIEWED BY ED LOPEZ. pg. 60  NARA Record Number: 1994.03.08.13:30:54:000007

(19) JOHN MARTINO: OS/SAG FILES PROVIDED TO THE HSCA, pg 11  NARA Record Number: 1993.07.21.09:15:26:960620

(20) IBID

(21) Florida Passenger Lists, 1898-1963 for Drexel Gibson A3995 – Miami, Florida, 1957-1963

(22) JOHN MARTINO: OS/SAG FILES PROVIDED TO THE HSCA, pg 5 NARA Record Number: 1993.07.21.09:15:26:960620

(23)  JOHN MARTINO: OS/SAG FILES PROVIDED TO THE HSCA, pg 8 NARA Record Number: 1993.07.21.09:15:26:960620

(24)  JOHN MARTINO: OS/SAG FILES PROVIDED TO THE HSCA, pg 5 NARA Record Number: 1993.07.21.09:15:26:960620

(25) Ancestry.com. Florida Death Index, 1877-1998 [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations Inc, 2004. Original data: State of Florida. Florida Death Index, 1877-1998. Florida: Florida Department of Health, Office of Vital Records, 1998.

 

A Swan, A Scituate, Massachusetts Radio Station and a Dripping Cuban

Love him or hate him, David Atlee Phillips was good at what he did.  Like many in the CIA, David Phillip’s career began after WWII.  He was a gunner in the Army Air Corps, and his plane was shot down leading to his capture(1).  For one year after his capture, Phillips served as the escape committee’s director, helping soldiers escape German captivity, until he eventually escaped himself and reported to General Omar Bradley (2).

Phillips’ career was by all standards a successful one.  He was involved in almost every major event in the Latin American region, rising to the level of Head of the Western Hemisphere.  The biographic profile of Phillips below, demonstrates his desire to be an actor early on in his life.  This career path was derailed by WWII, but those acting skills, the creative mind that wanted to be a part of theater, made him the perfect operator in the world of propaganda and psychological operations.  You can see in this document, the awards that he received in the “cause of freedom.”  Phillips was also recognized for helping to receive President Kennedy to Mexico City in 1962.

 BIOGRAPHIC PROFILE OF PHILLIPS, DAVID ATLEE NARA Record Number: 104-10136-10358 Phillips

David Phillps was a journalist in Chile when he was recruited into the CIA in the early 1950’s becoming an undercover asset specializing in propaganda.   His storied career led him to be involved in many cold war operations that were vital to the United States interests in the hemisphere.  His obituary matched his CIA biography but adds to the details.

Mr. Phillips was present when the C.I.A., with President Dwight D. Eisenhower’s blessing, toppled the Government of Jacobo Arbenz Guzman in Guatemala in 1954. He was a lecturer in Havana and a businessman in Lebanon before going to Washington in 1960 when the C.I.A. planned to duplicate the Guatemalan feat in Cuba – an effort that foundered in the Bay of Pigs.

Mr. Phillips served as station chief in the Dominican Republic and in Rio de Janeiro. His last assignment was as the head of the Western Hemisphere division, during which, he said, he ordered agents in Chile to distance themselves from the people then plotting the overthrow of President Allende, a Marxist.(3)

David Phillips received a tremendous amount of credit for directing the psychological warfare operations (Operation Sherwood) under his pseudonym, Paul D. Langevin (4).  Phillips’ psychological warfare operation was so successful, that the CIA, which was entertaining the use of assassination to topple the government, never got out of the discussion stages because the government fell (5).  Phillips had a budget of  “$2.7 million budget for “psychological warfare and political action” and “subversion”(6).”

You can see that Phillips, through Operation Sherwood, was a central part of this operation:

(8)

After Fidell Castro came into power in Cuba, the CIA began it’s planning to topple his government and turned to the operatives that were successful in the removal of the Guatemalan government.  A special task force was created to address the Cuban situation on January 18, 1960.  The creation of Western Hemisphere branch 4, WH/4 (JMATE/JMART) was created with Jake Esterline at the helm, because of his success of PBSUCCESS (7).  By February 10 David Atlee Phillips was in a planning session to help plan propaganda activities against Fidell (9).  At the first “official” meeting of the WH/4 group on March 9, David Phillips was named Propaganda Officer and giving him oversight of Phil Toomey the psychological strategist (10).

Who better to to run the propaganda machine against Castro than David Phillips?  With the success of operation PBSUCCESS virtually on the basis of Phillips operations, he was the logical choice to tackle the situation in Cuba.  The commendations he received for this operation indicated that there was nothing in the history of psychological warfare that even came close to what he accomplished.

One of the main thrusts of Phillips domain was an operation similar to the work done in WWII through The Voice of America.  This portion of the operation required the construction of two radio towers on Swan Island.  Thomas Cabot became the president of The Gibralter Steamship Company, created with the soul purpose of building this secret radio station.

In 1960, a Central Intelligence Agency cover called Gibraltar Steamship Company (which didn’t own any steamships and whose president was Cabot) owned and established Radio Swan on Swan Island, a covert black operation to win supporters for U.S. policies and discredit Fidel Castro(11).

The construction of this station was no small feat.  It required the cooperation of the Navy, The Seabees, The Coast Guard, Immigration and Naturalization Service, and the Federal Aviation Administration.  In April, David Phillips in a presentation to the Director of the Central Intelligence Agency, Allen Dulles, that the Swan Station would be operational and  broadcasting propaganda into Cuba by May 17(12).

A secondary radio station was utilized for the propaganda operations against Fidel Castro.  This was WRUL  transmitting out of Scituate, Massachusetts.

Patriot Ledger, August 10, 2010
WRUL RADIO, Scituate, Massachusetts, Patriot Ledger August 10, 2010

WRUL, a short wave radio station originally began as W1XAL, and its broadcast studio was at the Harvard Club, on Commonwealth Ave. in Boston.  In 1939 the radio station was needed for a covert British operation at the time Great Britain declared war on Germany.  At this time, the radio station was given the call letters, WRUL which stood for World Radio University Listeners.  The radio station was used by the government of Norway in 1940 to help counter German transmissions to their merchant ships, that were directing them to dock at AXIS ports.  By 1942, the United States Government had taken the station over and the Voice of America was born(13).

Transmitters at WRUL Facility, Scituate, MA

The US Government had set soldiers at the sight of the radio towers to guard it from sabotage (14).  There were German spies that were dropped of along the Eastern Coast, and Scituate had a sighting of two spies.  In addition, there was a German uniform found buried in the sand of the beach near where the WRUL towers were located.  One veteran of the era reports a German was killed near a tower, possibly WRUL, but that the story was suppressed to keep hysteria from spreading throughout the area (15).

The radio station was used for the propaganda machine that David Phillips ran, up to the Bay of Pigs.  Phillips worked closely with the Voice of America’s director, Henry Loomis (16).  Phillips received commendations for his work with Voice of America in 1968. By this time, the stations offices were in NY, while the transmitters remained in Scituate, MA (17).  However, this was a very different operation for David Phillips than the one he ran for Operation PBSUCCESS in Guatemala.  According to the OFFICIAL HISTORY OF THE , BAY OF PIGS OPERATION VOLUME III EVOLUTION OF CIA’s ANTI-CASTRO POLICIES, 1959-JANUARY 1961 David Phillps spent a lot of energy into making sure the many different factions of Cuban exiles, with their own interests, had time on the broadcasts from WMUR and a proposal was put forth to give the different factions of Cubans a rotating schedule of time on WMUR starting on December 1, 1960.  In Guatemala, he controlled a unified message, with a small team of people.  For this operation, he was stationed in Washington, New York, and MIAMI and was under orders to ensure that the different factions of Cubans were given time on the airwaves (18).

There were some strange suggestions for the use of the SWAN Station.  One suggestion to David Phillips from his superiors was to constantly broadcast Fidel Castro’s speeches, with the thoughts that the Cuban population would become bored with the leader.  Another proposed broadcast was to read an article titled, “An American Mother’s Terrifying Story – Fidel Castro Raped My Teenage Daughter” (19).  The broadcast theme of the Swan Station was “The Revolution Betrayed”.  David Phillips said that The Revolution Betrayed:

Hammered across the idea that Castro had double crossed the Cuban people by abandoning the programs  and promises that originally had won him support.  None of the CIA’s propaganda, spoken or printed, ever urged the population to rise up against Castro.  This appeal, suicidal before the invasion, would be used when, and if, the Provisional Government obtained a lodgement on the island (20).

One faction of Cuban revolutionaries was Frente Revolucionario Democratico (FRD).  Phillips who had been a newspaper man was actively producing propaganda on multiple fronts.  One example of this is found in this cable to the Mexico City Station in which Phillips is requesting the assistance of E. Howard Hunt and other members of the Mexico City Station to support a newspaper designed to provide support for the Frente Revolucionario Democratico (FRD).  Phillips wanted to coordinate the newspaper articles with broadcasts recorded by members of the FRD for the SWAN station.

MEMORANDUM: UNRESOLVED JMNET PROBLEMS RE MEXICO (21)

Phillips operation with the FRD(AMCIGAR)(22) was in full force in August, with money being deposited in accounts for E. Howard Hunt to fund the efforts.  This was a group that Phillips had worked with prior to the Bay of Pigs.  A deposit into a Swiss bank account was made in the amount of $75,000 as a Memorandum from the Finance Department stated in August (23).  From that account the AMCIGAR program was given $20,000 from this account on August 11, 1960, and there was a request for additional funds for twelve students waiting for Walter C. Twicker (E. Howard Hunt (24)).  By October, the FRD manifesto was completed and waiting to be approved for publication (25).  While a part of this cable is still redacted, it indicates that there would information going to the press as agreed to by Twicker (E. Howard Hunt).  There is much more to the story of the AMCIGAR operations that can be found in Jefferson Morely’s book, Our Man in Mexico.  In his book he details the difficulties that the CIA had with the AMCIGARs from the perspective of Winston Scott, the Station Chief of Mexico City.  This was Phillips operation and it they were a part of the propaganda machine that was geared up for the build-up to the Bay of Pigs Operation.

David Phillips however, was also making proposals for operations to add to the propaganda machine.  In the CIA’s own historical review of the Bay of Pigs, the historian notes, David Phillips acting roots and their influence on this proposed plan (26).  At one time, David Phillips had been interested in becoming an actor, and had been pursuing this as a career prior to WWII(27).  The proposed ideas from Phillips mind would require a person with great acting skills to pull off the plan. In the cable, Phillips himself requests a person who” ….must be a superb actor who can convincingly maintain role in spite of skillful probing by dubious newsman.”  The plot of this plan was to have a fake kidnapping of a Cuban national.  The victim would be placed on a “Russian freighter” that he would escape from in Turkey.  The communication states, “Shortly after a Russian boat homeward bound from Cuba passes through Bosphorosa a dripping Cuban climbs ashore in Turkey (28).”

In his description of the candidate for this operation, Phillips wanted to have a candidate who was well known in Havana so that they would be “missed”.  The person had to be able to memorize thousands of details so that they would be able to stand the media scrutiny.  The final part of this plan included that, “After brief but dramatic exposure to the press an “attempt” would be made on subject’s life. For this reason he will go underground so that “they” will not liquidate him (29).” This is quite the elaborate plan, that was not based in fact, but would give Phillips some really good material for either WMUR or the Swan Station.  Phillips recommendation for recruitment was to tell the potential recruit that the CIA really believed that there were Cuban prisoners being sent to Russia, but that they had been unable to prove it.  To reward the volunteer Phillips suggested time in Paris and permission to return to Cuba with the invading forces as a hero.  This operation was proposed on August 24, 1960.  It was reviewed by Allen Dulles, Gerneral Cabal, and Richard Helms.  It did not get permission to launch the operation, however, Richard Helms approved finding a candidate for the operation, but ordered them not to tell the subject the plan.  Helms directed that any further communications about this potential operation had to go through him (30).

There were assassination programs that are documented by the CIA historian.  It appears that these programs were kept outside of the JMATE group.  This included the operations involving CIA Agent Bill Harvey (ZRRIFLE) and his relationship with the mafia, and his operations that were eventually shut down by Robert Kennedy (31).   In addition, there was a program for assassination called AMHINT that was brought up in a meeting with Jake Esterline and Phillips, it is documented by the CIA historian that the operations for the Bay of Pigs, did not include an assassinations operation.  The historian notes that the AMHINT operation was run with members of the FRD, a group with direct contact with Phillips.   There was a request for silenced rifles, for an attempted assassination on a Cuban Official.  The CIA did not approve the operation. The author does make note that the Swan Station was used to broadcast propaganda that Che Guevera  had been assassinated, to annoy the Cuban Officials, even though at the time he was not yet dead(32).

David Phillips was one of the many CIA agents who felt that the Kennedy brothers had betrayed the Cuban people at the Bay of Pigs.  His career continued with the CIA with much success.  After the Bay of Pigs he was assigned to the Mexico City Station, and oversaw two operations that connected to Lee Harvey Oswald over the course three months prior to the assassination, one inside of the Untied States in New Orleans (AMSPELL) and one in Mexico City (LIERODE).  There were two other operations that Oswald ran into just prior to the assassination, LIENVOY and LIEMPTY(33).  These operations and the fact that they were still secret at the time of Phillips death may have contributed to the belief by those in the assassination research community to point their lens in his direction.  Then again, knowing about these operations, in some ways raises more questions about this Cold Warrior.  David Phillips believed in his secrecy oath, and went to his grave holding secrets that were not ready to be shared.

In honor of David Atlee Phillip’s birthday this week I leave you with lyrics written about him by his nephew, musician Sean Phillips:

Impressions of David Atlee Phillips (1988)

 Sometimes an actor, sometimes a fan,
sometimes a chief, always a man,
Loved by the women, and feared by the men,
who will put Humpty Dumpty back together again?

Scenes burnt beneath his boots from 20,000 Ft.
twice he fell into the mist, there was no time for sleep.
Under fire in arid office, under strain in jungle rains,
he cried once to a tree for hours, yet he carried well his pain.

3 older brothers shared the cause, the truth now if it kills,
the battle rages on today, the war is fueled by wills.
He tried to help the weak survive, when being stepped on by the strong,
when chaos reigned the world of reason, an infant full of dawn

His children are alert and brave, Their fight is not denied,
they roam the world and carry on, they would like to be defied,
2 women brought them into life, his memory lives in them,
and we are here because he’s gone, we know who was his friend

If all men were angels, go the words, we seek to hope this so,
he made mistakes as do we all, but which are those we know,
we shan’t be sad, he lived quite full, he knew this is no bloody game,
and if God forgives transgressions, then I guess we all can do the same.

Respect and love are intertwined, his dignity not bled,
Have a good time I said in parting, he knew just what I meant
So pass in peace my Father’s brother, I feel you were my friend.
It’s nice to know that you have found, that this is not the end (34)

Matt “The Hitman” Scheufele

References

(1) David Atlee Phillips Obituary, New York Times

(2) Is David Atlee Phillips AKA Maurice Bishop? You Make the Call  By William Kelly, Posted in The Education Forum, 12 September 2006

(3) David Atlee Phillips Obituary, New York Times

(4) FOREIGN RELATIONS OF THE UNITED STATES, 1952–1954, GUATEMALA

(5) CIA and Assassinations: The Guatemala 1954 Documents  Edited by Kate Doyle and Peter Kornbluh

(6) CIA and Assassinations: The Guatemala 1954 Documents  Edited by Kate Doyle and Peter Kornbluh

(7) OFFICIAL HISTORY OF THE , BAY OF PIGS OPERATION VOLUME III EVOLUTION OF CIA’s ANTI-CASTRO POLICIES, 1959-JANUARY 1961, Page 86

(8) The CIA in Guatemala by Jason Clingerman on February 13, 2012

(9) OFFICIAL HISTORY OF THE , BAY OF PIGS OPERATION VOLUME III EVOLUTION OF CIA’s ANTI-CASTRO POLICIES, 1959-JANUARY 1961, Page 47

(10) OFFICIAL HISTORY OF THE , BAY OF PIGS OPERATION VOLUME III EVOLUTION OF CIA’s ANTI-CASTRO POLICIES, 1959-JANUARY 1961, Page 57

(11) Wikipedia on Answers.com: Thomas Dudley Cabot

(12) OFFICIAL HISTORY OF THE , BAY OF PIGS OPERATION VOLUME III EVOLUTION OF CIA’s ANTI-CASTRO POLICIES, 1959-JANUARY 1961, Page 57

(13) Scituate’s radio station helped save the world, Jim O’Keefe, PATRIOT LEDGER, August 10, 2010

(14) The Global Medium on the Massachusetts Coast: A short history of WRUL Radio Boston, WNYW Radio New York Worldwide and WYFR Family Radio.   Based on a              Presentation by Lou Josephs

(15) Recalling Nazi spies off the New England coast, and a mystery on a Scituate beach, By Jim Rose, PATRIOT LEDGER, November 11, 2008

(16) OFFICIAL HISTORY OF THE , BAY OF PIGS OPERATION VOLUME III EVOLUTION OF CIA’s ANTI-CASTRO POLICIES, 1959-JANUARY 1961, Page 212

(17) The Global Medium on the Massachusetts Coast: A short history of WRUL Radio Boston, WNYW Radio New York Worldwide and WYFR Family Radio.   Based on a               Presentation by Lou Josephs

(18) OFFICIAL HISTORY OF THE , BAY OF PIGS OPERATION VOLUME III EVOLUTION OF CIA’s ANTI-CASTRO POLICIES, 1959-JANUARY 1961, Page 212

(19) OFFICIAL HISTORY OF THE , BAY OF PIGS OPERATION VOLUME III EVOLUTION OF CIA’s ANTI-CASTRO POLICIES, 1959-JANUARY 1961, Page 218

(20) OFFICIAL HISTORY OF THE , BAY OF PIGS OPERATION VOLUME III EVOLUTION OF CIA’s ANTI-CASTRO POLICIES, 1959-JANUARY 1961, Page 219

(21) Memorandum from David Atlee Phillips to Miss Thorp, August 1960

(23) NARA Record Number: 1994.04.12.15:55:23:130005 Reel 26, Folder J – FRENTE REVOLUTIONARIO DEMOCRATICA; FRD-MEXICO.

(24) FOREIGN RELATIONS OF THE UNITED STATES, 1952–1954, GUATEMALA  Persons and Pseudonyms

(25) CABLE: ORRISON REQUEST FOLLOWING FROM AMCIGAR FOR UTILIZATION

(26) OFFICIAL HISTORY OF THE , BAY OF PIGS OPERATION VOLUME III EVOLUTION OF CIA’s ANTI-CASTRO POLICIES, 1959-JANUARY 1961, Page 231

(27) Arlington Cemetary: David Atlee Phillips  Sergeant, United States Army   Central Intelligence Agency Operative

(28) OFFICIAL HISTORY OF THE , BAY OF PIGS OPERATION VOLUME III EVOLUTION OF CIA’s ANTI-CASTRO POLICIES, 1959-JANUARY 1961, Page 231

(29) OFFICIAL HISTORY OF THE , BAY OF PIGS OPERATION VOLUME III EVOLUTION OF CIA’s ANTI-CASTRO POLICIES, 1959-JANUARY 1961, Page 231

(30) OFFICIAL HISTORY OF THE , BAY OF PIGS OPERATION VOLUME III EVOLUTION OF CIA’s ANTI-CASTRO POLICIES, 1959-JANUARY 1961, Page 232

(31) Spartacus-Educational, William K. Harvey

(32) OFFICIAL HISTORY OF THE , BAY OF PIGS OPERATION VOLUME III EVOLUTION OF CIA’s ANTI-CASTRO POLICIES, 1959-JANUARY 1961, Page 285-286

(33) Our Man in Mexico: Winston Scott and the Hidden History of the CIA pg. 169, University Press of Kansas,  Jefferson Morely

(34) Impressions of David Atlee Phillips (1988), By Shawn Phillips